No matter what your pizza preference, chances are, you’ll find a spot in the city that caters to your taste. Whether you prefer a deep-dish pie or something thin crust, a variety of veggies or an assortment of meats, your perfect spot is out there. Our readers selected four great spots to enjoy the Italian staple.
Tony’s Pizza Palace
The fact that Tony’s Pizza Palace placed first in the Best Tried & True category in our 2018 Best Restaurants issue speaks volumes. It’s a northside staple, a spot passed down through the generations. And once you take a bite of a Tony’s pie, it’s not hard to understand the appeal.
Sal’s Deluxe is a classic choice – prosciutto, capicollo, tomato sauce, and bocconcini cheese. You have the option of creating your own pie, but when the Sal’s Deluxe is so perfectly balanced, why bother? And, if you’re going with the whole family, make sure to get the XL size – you’ll want all the slices you can get.
This Cromdale spot makes stone-baked thin crust pizzas that you absolutely need to try, no matter what your topping preferences are.
Panini’s specializes in adding a bit of a twist to classics, and it pulls it off with finesse. If you prefer to keep things simple, go for the margherita plus – it’s a classic margherita with the addition of fresh tomato slices and feta cheese for a little extra tang. Or, sample the tried and true combination of chicken, pesto, ricotta, roasted red peppers, with the addition of banana peppers adding a little spice.
Or, if you’ve never met a meat lovers’ pizza you haven’t loved, the loaded Italian is a must try – generous portions of Italian sausage,capicollo, and meatballs top the pizza, which also swaps out the regular tomato sauce for a meaty Bolognese beef sauce. That’s right – there’s even meat in the sauce. Panini’s is not messing around.
We wrote about this spot on the south side back in our December 2017 issue, when it was a new addition to the city – and we’re still loving its wood fired pizzas.
Vaticano embraces its name, filling the space with frescoes and a massive pizza oven that seems transported straight out of Italy. And, while Vaticano has several pasta options and antipasti to kick off your meal, pizza is where the spot truly shines.
If you’re looking for a pizza that is unapologetically decadent, go for the St. Joseph – the pie is topped with cream shallot sauce, guanciale, Italian sausage, pecorino and two perfectly fried eggs on top. The richness means you may want to split this one. Or, opt for something a little lighter like the St. Vincent – a fresh, vegetable-packed pizza topped with pesto and fresh homemade ricotta.